Export thread

Google filtering torrent results

#1



JCM

It’s taken a while, but Google has finally caved in to pressure from the entertainment industries including the MPAA and RIAA. The search engine now actively censors terms including BitTorrent, torrent, utorrent, RapidShare and Megaupload from its instant and autocomplete services. The reactions from affected companies and services are not mild, with BitTorrent Inc., RapidShare and Vodo all speaking out against this act of commercial censorship.

The entertainment industries’ quest to root out piracy on the Internet has yet again resulted in commercial censorship. A few weeks ago Google announced that it would start filtering “piracy related” terms from its ‘Autocomplete‘ and ‘Instant‘ services and today they quietly rolled out this questionable feature.

Without a public notice Google has compiled a seemingly arbitrary list of keywords for which auto-complete is no longer available. Although the impact of this decision does not currently affect full search results, it does send out a strong signal that Google is willing to censor its services proactively, and to an extent that is far greater than many expected.

Among the list of forbidden keywords are “uTorrent”, a hugely popular piece of entirely legal software and “BitTorrent”, a file transfer protocol and the name of San Fransisco based company BitTorrent Inc. As of today, these keywords will no longer be suggested by Google when you type in the first letter, nor will they show up in Google Instant.

All combinations of the word “torrent” are also completely banned. This means that “Ubuntu torrent” will not be suggested as a user types in Ubuntu, and the same happens to every other combination ending in the word torrent. This of course includes the titles of popular films and music albums, which is the purpose of Google’s banlist.

TorrentFreak contacted BitTorrent Inc. for a reaction, and Simon Morris told TorrentFreak that he believes the scope of this filter is too broad.

“We respect Google’s right to determine algorithms to deliver appropriate search results to user requests. That being said, our company’s trademarked name is fairly unique, and we’re pretty confident that anyone typing the first six or seven letters deserves the same easy access to results as with any other company search,” Morris said.

“A quick search for ‘BitTorrent’ currently returns a variety of legitimate and useful links, including company information, our software, our open-source protocol, and more. What Google may not realize is that our technology is used for many purposes that provide significant value to the technology industry, companies, artists and consumers at large,” he added.
Even though its just autofill and insta-search, its seems odd to go after the torrent client, which are also used by Universities, Freeware distribution and the like....

Maybe censoring "movie/game/album name" + "torrent" would be more effective?


#2

Jay

Jay



FILTERING MY TORRENT SEARCHES? ARRRRGGGGHHHH


#3

SpecialKO

SpecialKO

I'm wondering if some background legal pressure came to bear. If there's one thing the MPAA/RIAA aren't short of (yet), it's money and lawyers. A threat to file a service injunction until the legal question could be resolved, with enough money behind it, would be enough to rattle Google.


#4



Joe Johnson

Phweew! Finally, no more illegal downloads!


#5

Dave

Dave

Pfft. I doubt Google would bow to such pressure. Hell, all they'd have to do is say, "Okay, bring all the pressure you want. I think we'll start blocking your movie/artist/etc from our searches."

I think JCM has the right idea with the filter, though. In the end right now nothing changes if you already know what you are looking for.


#6

Jay

Jay

I just did a few searches right now... I didn't notice much of a difference.


#7



JCM

I dont know about xbox and ps3, but most downloads i get are from sites that I download from a link. (ipa, psp csos, ds roms, bbc shows and the odd song), so as a pirate in Brazil, it doesnt affect me except for when Im going to download legal sofware.

Torrent is getting slower for anything that isnt the latest episode/album, but its a pretty damn good tool for free software distribution like br office and linux distros.


#8

SpecialKO

SpecialKO

Pfft. I doubt Google would bow to such pressure. Hell, all they'd have to do is say, "Okay, bring all the pressure you want. I think we'll start blocking your movie/artist/etc from our searches."
A legal service injunction doesn't take long to get, and it would shut down their search engine entirely.

And Google will never do that to the people behind popular pop culture icons/products that millions of people will search for. Not only is it counter to their mission statement, everyone who wants to search for those terms will go to Bing.


#9

Mathias

Mathias

my question is how does the RIAA stay in business?

http://www.afterdawn.com/news/artic...2008_recovered_less_than_1_million_from_suits

As a company they use probably the most archaic and idiotic business practices short of being called Chrysler.


#10

SpecialKO

SpecialKO

my question is how does the RIAA stay in business?

http://www.afterdawn.com/news/artic...2008_recovered_less_than_1_million_from_suits

As a company they use probably the most archaic and idiotic business practices short of being called Chrysler.
Because they still have billions of dollars.


#11

Null

Null

I hate to agree with Mathias, but he's right. Their fight against piracy is effectively shoveling their own money right into a furnace, without the benefit of generating heat.


#12

Jay

Jay

short of being called Chrysler.
ROFL


Top