We ate like champs. Then again, we went at length to talk to the locals to validate what we had in our guide and went to really good (and generally as inexpensive as the Euro can get) restos and ate REALLY good. Where did you go again?
Here was the trip with some notes. We drove a rental car the whole way.
Rome: 2 Nights
St Peters Basillica was amazing, as was just walking around. Great architecture everywhere.
Naples: 1 Night
The worst place we went in Italy. Absolutely filthy, only place in Italy I was scared. We saw 1 working streetlight. People tried to sell me stolen goods that matched what was in my bag.
Sorrento: 2 Nights
Stayed at a great place, drove the Amalfi coast, was incredible. Videotaped the entire drive back at sunset.
Florence: 1 Night
Saw the Duomo (wow), went to an opera. Tried a local tripe dish, was very good, but surprisingly tasted just like spagghetios
Venice: 2 Nights
Cool town, got lost repeatedly (which was really fun). Canal smells like ass. St Marks was claustraphobic and unpleasant. Generally really great town. Had some local seafood, it was all whipped fish (Baccala stuff). Very traditional, kind of hard to keep down by the end (very rich and VERY fishy)
Cinque Terre/Vernazza: 2 Nights
Great food, great gelato. Did 4 of the 5 towns walk. Found a store that sold wine bottles with Hitler, Mussolini, El Duce, etc. on them (WTF!) and went to a nude beach. Then walked through abandoned train tunnel (shortcut from beach) and thought we would die. Great time (seriously).
Tuscanny: 3 nights
Stayed in southern tuscanny at a vinyard/agritourism place, best place we stayed, bar none. Went to sienna to finish souvenier shopping, another cool Duomo but at that point I was a bit churched out. Went to a national park and went horseback riding. Went to Saturnia Spa a sulfur spring. Surprisingly the wine at the agritourism place wasn't great, but their Grappa was (for those that don't know, Grappa is almost identical to tequila).
Rome: 1 night
Went back to Trastavere for one last good meal, then went back to the hotel, woke up at 3:00 AM and caught a flight back to the US. Airplane company lost my bag.