Export thread

Neil Young's Making an MP3 Player

Mar 21, 2014#1

Chad Sexington

I admit, I'm a sucker for triangles, so aesthetically, I want one.

On the other hand, I wonder if the plastic for these will be made without using oil? Why has no one asked Mr. Young that question?

(I know the answer.)

Anyway, colour me interested. I could use a new MP3 device since my iPod's battery now lasts approximately an hour and a half.

Mar 21, 2014#2

Shakey

Unless you're going to start buying the lossless music from their store, or converting your CD's to FLAC or something, don't bother. For just MP3's you'll probably be better off buying something cheaper and smaller.

Mar 21, 2014#3

Chad Sexington

(Almost) all of my music is already in FLAC

Mar 21, 2014#4

Shakey

It would probably be perfect for you then. Almost all the complaints I've seen have basically come down to whether most people can really tell the difference between mp3's and lossless and if it's really needed. The hardware seems to be solid, so it should deliver what it claims.

If I had the cash I'd pick it up. It's going to be $100 cheaper if you get in on the kickstarter, so if you want one I'd go for it.

Mar 21, 2014#5

Chad Sexington

Yes, my friends often make fun of me (and probably justly) for being an audiophile. I admit readily there's a chance I only imagine a difference.

Mar 21, 2014#6

Shakey

I think it's a lot like high end HD video. There's a point where most people won't notice a difference. Even if you can't notice it, if you're a film buff and want the best experience possible, you're going to want it. If music is your passion, who cares if other people say you don't need it. The idea that you're getting closer to the studio quality recording the musician intended means a lot to some people. This player is meant for them.

Mar 21, 2014#7

Chad Sexington

Shakey said:
I think it's a lot like high end HD video. There's a point where most people won't notice a difference. Even if you can't notice it, if you're a film buff and want the best experience possible, you're going to want it. If music is your passion, who cares if other people say you don't need it. The idea that you're getting closer to the studio quality recording the musician intended means a lot to some people. This player is meant for them.

I think that's well-put.

Mar 21, 2014#8

Celt Z

Well, I hope Neil Young will remember a Southern Man's already got an iPod, anyhow.

Mar 21, 2014#9

PatrThom

Celt Z said:
Well, I hope Neil Young will remember a Southern Man's already got an iPod, anyhow.

Wouldn't it be something if Skynyrd put out their own player? Heh.

--Patrick

Forums