Krisken, I respect you, and you play with dolls like I do, so you know I have nothing against you.
But seasons 2 and 3, you are so damn wrong that I must believe you haven't seen them since they aired and are letting time cloud your memory. We just watched this stuff--it's great. It actually works a little better when we don't have to wait a week between episodes.
I don't feel Buffy really starts to fall apart until the "Jonathan" episode.