I've never seen Saw (heehee), but from what I've heard, Fade it correct. The first one is different from the others. It seems like the sequels were made because there was an audience crying out for more gore. If I want to watch a scary movie, I make it perfectly clear that I don't want a shocky-shocky movie or a just-plain-gross movie. I want a movie that's going to mess with me, taunt me, and possibly make me feel like I'm going crazy/being watched the next time I'm home alone at night. In fact, if anyone knows any good movies that are really scary on that kind of psychological level, let me know. Lately, all I see are "jump-out-at-you" scary movies.