The "New" Harley Quinn
- Thread starter rac3r_x
- Start date
- Status
A
Andromache
it makes me miss Ledger's Joker.
:waah:
They did? Link?
No one is ever going to replace Ledger as the Joker in a live action film in the same way that no one had ever done a better Joker in the cartoons as Mark Hamil. That being said... the costume was fine, the dialog was fine, but the voice really threw it off for me.
They did? Link?[/QUOTE]
The didn't, I think he's saying they SHOULDN'T even consider it, which I agree with.
P
Philosopher B.
I thought the film was decent. I didn't mind the Joker as much as the eagerness with with she dispatched the dude.
Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaah. I get loving something but why put so much effort into something that isn't YOURS. You want to be a filmmaker (and let's face it, most of the people who do this sort of thing do)? Go do your own thing, get noticed, etc. No one will take this seriously, even if it's really well done (which I have yet to see a fan-film that is REALLY well done and not cringe inducing at some point).
Yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaah. I get loving something but why put so much effort into something that isn't YOURS. You want to be a filmmaker (and let's face it, most of the people who do this sort of thing do)? Go do your own thing, get noticed, etc. No one will take this seriously, even if it's really well done (which I have yet to see a fan-film that is REALLY well done and not cringe inducing at some point).[/QUOTE]
Well I wouldn't call it a fan film but:
That pretty much beats the movie in any way imaginable
So what your saying is the people in the movie decides if it's a fan film or not? That's bullshit.
So what your saying is the people in the movie decides if it's a fan film or not? That's bullshit.[/QUOTE]
No. If a group of people make a SPOOF using oscar nominated actors then it's just a SPOOF using oscar nominated actors. If a 2nd year film school nerd makes a Wolverine short film with his friends it's a FAN FILM.
That's the difference.
So what your saying is the people in the movie decides if it's a fan film or not? That's bullshit.[/QUOTE]
No. If a group of people make a SPOOF using oscar nominated actors then it's just a SPOOF using oscar nominated actors. If a 2nd year film school nerd makes a Wolverine short film with his friends it's a FAN FILM.
That's the difference.[/QUOTE]
Your comparing apples to oranges then. One is clearly a parody while the other is an attempt at drama.
Oh and here.
So what your saying is the people in the movie decides if it's a fan film or not? That's bullshit.[/QUOTE]
No. If a group of people make a SPOOF using oscar nominated actors then it's just a SPOOF using oscar nominated actors. If a 2nd year film school nerd makes a Wolverine short film with his friends it's a FAN FILM.
That's the difference.[/QUOTE]
Your comparing apples to oranges then.[/QUOTE]
I have no idea what we are now arguing about and I'm not comparing anything to anything
.
Someone posted a fan film. I said most of them suck.
Icarus posted a spoof or parody of GIJOE. I said it was cool.
I'm not comparing them. I'm saying they are different.
ElJuski
Staff member
Yeah a spoof is not a fanfilm. Also, fairy tales are part of a literary mythology, and therefore, also not fanfilms. Making a shitty Joker movie for your production class and trying to be super nerdy cool is a fanfilm.
It's kind of a shame, really, that it takes so much for an independent filmaker to be taken seriously. But then again, that 'so much' is talent.
THIS ISN'T REGIONAL THEATRE, YOU GUYS! >:|
It's kind of a shame, really, that it takes so much for an independent filmaker to be taken seriously. But then again, that 'so much' is talent.
THIS ISN'T REGIONAL THEATRE, YOU GUYS! >:|
The GI Joe thing is a spoof due to format and content, not the famous faces in it. It's the same as Weird Al making songs like Dare To Be Stupid in the format of Devo. That's still a spoof.
You know, the greatest filmmaker in the world who is making his 2,000 dollar budget Captain Marvel fanflic that stars his buddy's cousin who was a background actor in The Hulk and his girlfriend who "just wants to do sum actin'" is still going to suck for many reasons. Even if the director has a great eye and tons of talent. In the end, unless he does something REALLY amazing no one will care. Because it's a Captain Marvel fanfilm.
Just like the REALLY promising writer who can't figure out why nobody takes his Harry Potter/Twlight stories seriously and gives him a book deal. When that's what you are doing no one will take you seriously.
Just like the REALLY promising writer who can't figure out why nobody takes his Harry Potter/Twlight stories seriously and gives him a book deal. When that's what you are doing no one will take you seriously.
ElJuski
Staff member
F'sho. I should also mention that there are basically genres of art that basically get wadded up in the piss-bin (as Vonnegut would put it), which are but not limited to: fantasy, science-fiction, and comic books. All too many people think they have the chops to muster up well-defined pieces of art in these fields; all too many people fail end up reinforcing the stereotype that fantasy, science-fiction and comic books are for cat-owning basement dwellers in their mama's midwestern home.
YES.
---------- Post added at 12:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:46 PM ----------
I should add though, do what you love, if you wanna make fanfilms or write harry potter/twilight then GO FOR IT. Have fun, that's more than most people do.
I just tire of hearing people say they don't get why no one takes them seriously as they doodle a sparkly vampire making love to Snape.
---------- Post added at 12:48 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:46 PM ----------
I should add though, do what you love, if you wanna make fanfilms or write harry potter/twilight then GO FOR IT. Have fun, that's more than most people do.
I just tire of hearing people say they don't get why no one takes them seriously as they doodle a sparkly vampire making love to Snape.
Shannow
Staff member
Sadly, this was also my reaction to this video.
A
Andromache
*smashes your skull mouth and teeth against a curb a few dozen times*
DO I DO A PASSABLE JOB AS A DENTIST DO YOU THINK?
*smashes your skull mouth and teeth against a curb a few dozen times*
DO I DO A PASSABLE JOB AS A DENTIST DO YOU THINK?[/QUOTE]
I laughed.
Loud.
People are staring.
I'm still laughing.
I turned it off at "KILLER HEADACHE!"
No.
Just, no.
No.
Just, no.
- Status