Prop 8 legal dance updated

[SpecialKO]

Since I couldn't resurrect the original thread...

The motion to vacate gay judge's overturning of Prop 8 has been filed.

Filers declare that Vaughn Walker, being gay and in a long-term relationship, was incapable of being impartial.

 

[sixpackshaker]

...was incapable of being impartial.

It should read, incapable of being discriminatory.

 

[SpecialKO]

He clearly doesn't recognize the threat represented by people exactly like himself.

 

[Chibibar]

so they are back on board that white judge can't rule on white issues? same with African judges? Chinese? Hispanic?

 

[Tress]

so they are back on board that white judge can't rule on white issues? same with African judges? Chinese? Hispanic?

None of that applies. The evil Gay Menace does not follow logic. All you need to know is that they are dangerous, and they are everywhere. Apparently they have even begun to infiltrate the justice system, posing as judges, no doubt in an attempt to spoil our glorious society from within.

 

[AshburnerX]

Yeah, it'll never pass muster. It's already well established that members of various ethnic groups CAN rule impartially on their own people, but even if they couldn't, it would be discriminatory to overturn their decisions based solely on the fact of membership. So unless the government is going to officially declare that Homosexuality is a choice (hint: It's not), they really have no basis for appeal.