Our party isn't balanced at all.
You're the only melee, and everyone else is magic. We have one kind-of healer. We have no stealthies, I only just now trained in Thievery, barely any perception, etc.
Also, Rathy, why does crunching the numbers matter so much? It's a once-a-day ability, and we have about one day every two months.
If somebody wants something, that's all the reason someone needs to be entitled to it.
Plus, here's the magic item breakdown:
Falagar: Goggles, Gauntlets, "Hedge Wizard's Gloves", Boots, 2 rituals, and more
Rathkor: Dagger, Polyglot Gem, The Green Ring
Tyrdin: Broach, something else
Helga: Nothing, but doesn't want robe
Sylvaria: Nothing, wants robe