Export thread

People in my family often ask me why I quit social media. It's a question I often avoid because explaining the reason why is something I find difficult to do. As much as I find language fascinating I also always feel flummoxed by it because I often feel I don't have the proper capacity within it to convey the complex thoughts that seem perfectly reasonable in my head but start to fall apart the moment I try to translate them into verbiage. The only way I've found to counteract this shortcoming is by way of long, winding narratives that seem to go nowhere but I promise if you stick with it until the end, it will come to a very non-satisfying conclusion. So buckle up, we're going to be getting nowhere fast.

This is going to be a very rough draft of something else I'll be writing elsewhere, you guys get to be my guinea pigs. It very well may not make sense.


Luddites

The word luddite today is a derogatory term used to describe someone who is opposed to technology. "A small-minded Luddite resisting progress" is the literal dictionary example used, clearly marking luddite as something that is laughable in today's age; a technophobe. But that's not what the Luddites were. History has since painted them as deserving of mockery, but the Luddite movement was a radical labor union started in England in the early 19th century opposing what they viewed as unfair practices using new technology to skirt the current labor laws. They took their name after Ned Ludd, a skilled weaver who, in the late 1700's found his way of life in jeopardy. He'd spent his life honing his craft, but was forced out of a job when the textile factory started adopting new machinery that could automate the weaving process, allowing them to fire the skilled workers they employed and hire unskilled workers at a fraction of the pay and in much smaller numbers. I know the free market types are going to say this is natural progress, of course a factory should seek to maximize profits and find cheaper ways to make their products, but the factory was already profitable. Is the goal of the factory to serve the community it sustains, or is the goal to maximize profits above all else? Capitalism says it's to maximize profits, because capitalism can't tell the difference between what is valuable and what is profitable, even if what is valuable for a community isn't always profitable. Sure, people may be happy to find that the textiles they buy are now cheaper, but would they really prefer that if they knew in what other ways those textiles were paid for? What the community paid to have them? What was lost in the name of profit?

Ned clearly didn't agree with this, and in the face of his entire way of life being taken away from him, he did the only rational thing he could think of. He broke into the factory and busted up the machine with a hammer.

Ned Ludd became something of a folk hero for this. It's why he became a symbol for the Luddite movement, named after him though he himself wasn't actually involved. There's even an old folk song about him, which the always based band Chumbawumba happened to record a rendition of:




The Luddites would band together in a secret society and do exactly what he did, breaking into factories and tearing down the machines. These people weren't against progress, or technology, they were against the forces of greed ruining their communities just for more money. They foresaw the coming industrial revolution as a process that would widen the wage gap, make the rich even richer and keep the poor poorer than they'd ever been. They were afraid that, if left unchecked, this kind of progress without conscience would lead to catastrophe.

*fast forward a couple hundred years*

Oh fuck we've got billionaires now.


Ol' Musky and Transhumanism


Elon Musk is one of those billionaires. He's a guy that took the money he got from one good idea and used it to buy a bunch of other shit he could take credit for. The richer he's gotten, the more brain worms he seems to have gotten, it's funny how that seems to work, and while he's deathly afraid that he might one day have to pay taxes, there is one thing he's in favor of regulating: AI. The only thing Musk fears is the belief that one day AI will come to a singularity event and humanity will be face to digital face with another conscious entity, one far more capable and far more durable, that may decide to pull a terminator and wipe us out, possibly with naked Arnolds. I'm talking the football head, not the Austrian guy, things don't always work like in the movies. After rallying for world governments to put restrictions on AI research and failing, he's since decided to pivot into another direction, using one of the companies he bought and took credit for to research neural interfacing between the human brain and computers. He believes the only way humanity can survive the arrival of AI is to merge with it, with all of us becoming cyborgs.

Transhumanism is the belief that humanity will evolve past our current physical limitations through the use of technology. Becoming cyborgs to think faster, be stronger, live longer, and overall become more and more superhuman. In a world where transhumanism comes to exist, those who choose not to enhance themselves are going to be at a severe disadvantage. A cyborg may be able to do thousands of computations more an hour than a mere flesh-brained human could, so why would an employer favor Marty Meatsack when Sandy Cyberdong is so much better at everything? Cyberdong is just a surname, get your head out of the gutter. In this future scenario, you either get chipped and link yourself to the growing hivemind of humanity, or you get left behind.


Honestly, even though I think Elon Musk is a garbage human being, I think he is mostly right in this regard. The only thing I disagree with him is in the timeline. Because this isn't something that will happen in the future, we're already there. We're all already cyborgs, it's just that instead of having the computer chip in our brains, it's in our pockets. I'm never more than a second away from accessing the internet. As a kid using dial-up, the internet was a place I went. Now, it's a place I live, I'm never without it. We as a society have reached a point where we have a constant sensory overload of information flooding us at all times, to the point that we feel its absence if it's gone. Have you ever been somewhere with poor cell service and no wifi? It's almost like being in a low oxygen scenario, you feel something is off. You keep instinctively reaching into your pocket to look up an answer only to remind yourself you can't. Your body is attempting to use a phantom limb that, for the moment, doesn't work. Constant connectivity is changing the very chemistry of our brains, and I'm just as addicted to it as anyone else. I like it, I need it, and I don't want to live without it, so then where does my hesitation come from? Why don't I welcome the merge?


The algorithm


Capitalism can't tell the difference between value and profit. And we've trained our AI systems that run the hivemind we connect to this same fault. From Amazon to Google to Facebook, algorithms collect our data in an attempt to better serve us. Things we want are offered to us faster, and for cheaper, than they've ever been before. Amazon can know the things you want to buy before you even realize you want them and offer them up to you in ads. Facebook will guess your interests and lead you to new communities to engage in faster than ever before, so what's the problem? Everyone's heard of people getting radicalized by the internet, and the reason is that the algorithm can't tell the difference between profit and value. All it knows is engagement. It knows that if it gets your attention, if it gets your views, if it gets your clicks, its succeeding. Any time you try to be a normal fucking person and take a break, it thinks its failing, and will double down to bring you back with whatever it can. It doesn't know -you- but instead knows trends and what gets the most engagement, knowing that the biggest rabbit holes full of the craziest shit is what keeps people engaged the most, and does everything it can to lead you there. And it will continue to get better and better at this, because it doesn't know how to stop. If the Luddites existed today, I'm fairly certain they'd be busting up facebook servers, and fighting against the "metaverse" that every corporation is fondling themselves over, thinking of the profits they can earn by keeping people as engaged, paying customers, not knowing what they're trading away for the process.

There's no stopping the future. It's coming no matter what. My only hope is that when it gets here, maybe we will have found a way to tell the difference between profit and value. But I doubt it.



Having written all this out now, I don't think I've done a good job at all of explaining my feelings. But I had to write something or it would burn my brain up thinking about it.

Ravenpoe said:

The richer he's gotten, the more brain worms he seems to have gotten, it's funny how that seems to work

Click to expand...

I will again call your attention to the following:

Dacher Keltner, a psychology professor at UC Berkeley, has been studying the influence of power on individuals. [...] He has consistently found that power, over time, makes one more impulsive, more reckless and less able to see things from others' points of view. It also leads one to be rude, more likely to cheat on one's spouse, less attentive to other people, and less interested in the experiences of others. Does that sound familiar? It turns out that power actually gives you brain damage.

Click to expand...

Sukhvinder Obhi, a neuroscientist at McMaster University in Ontario, recently examined the brain patterns of the powerful and the not so powerful [and] found that those with power are impaired in a specific neural process — mirroring — that leads to empathy... Perhaps most distressing is that in lab settings the powerful can't address this shortcoming even if told to try. Subjects in one study were told that their mirroring impulse was the issue and to make a conscious effort to relate to the experiences of others. They still couldn't do it. Effort and awareness made no difference in their abilities..

Click to expand...

(emphasis mine)

Ravenpoe said:

In this future scenario, you either get chipped and link yourself to the growing hivemind of humanity, or you get left behind.

Click to expand...

We've already had this. First* with telephone lines, then cable television, then cell phones, then Internet access, etc. There's no reason to assume that treadmill of necessity won't continue.

--Patrick
*not really first ever, just the first in this list.

PatrThom said:

We've already had this.

Click to expand...

I agree!

Ravenpoe said:

Because this isn't something that will happen in the future, we're already there

Click to expand...

See?

So in a longer version of this that's still taking shape for something else, I mention a personal anecdote of just how it is for my dad to connect with certain parts of the modern world all because he doesn't have an email address. Or any online presence at all. It's like he lives in a different world, one I occasionally have to be a bridge for.

This is interesting information

Robby78R said:

This is interesting information

Click to expand...

Ah fack the bots already found me

Ravenpoe said:

Ah fack the bots already found me

Click to expand...

Don't worry, I think in this time line that means Arnold wil come save you.

Bubble181 said:

Don't worry, I think in this time line that means Arnold wil come save you.

Click to expand...

Move it, football head!

Huh, you guys are funny.
Who else is a bot?

Robby78R said:

Huh, you guys are funny.
Who else is a bot?

Click to expand...

Ooh! Ooh! Me! Me!

Robby78R said:

Huh, you guys are funny.
Who else is a bot?

Click to expand...

No, I'm Spartacus!

Robby78R said:

Huh, you guys are funny.
Who else is a bot?

Click to expand...

You are, the guy with the generic name and profile pic who posted the exact same message to several other xenforo message boards.

Ravenpoe said:

You are, the guy with the generic name and profile pic who posted the exact same message to several other xenforo message boards.

Click to expand...

Now that I did not know. I did an IP search and his IP matched his chosen location. So if he is a scammer or someone acting in bad faith he's thorough.

Dave said:

Now that I did not know. I did an IP search and his IP matched his chosen location. So if he is a scammer or someone acting in bad faith he's thorough.

Click to expand...

It looks like most of the boards have already deleted the messages so I can't give a lot of examples, but:














Pretty common canvassing, make a bunch of different profiles under a bunch of different names under a bunch of different forums, post once to establish a presence, and then either start spamming from there or pass them off to someone else to start spamming.

Or the guy has a fetish for posting once on every forum, that also could be it.

That's a very interesting perspective, {name}! I would like to know more about this topic.

Even the OpenCore forum? Wow, that’s diverse.

—Patrick

The fact that a bot chose this thread to respond is pure comedy.

Tress said:

The fact that a bot chose this thread to respond is pure comedy.

Click to expand...

It's proving my point real well

This is getting crazy. I'll vouch for him. @Ravenpoe is a real person.

He's friends with a gopher tortoise who lives in his backyard. And, as everone knows, they have a notoriously low threshold when dealing with procedurally based entities. So, there's no way he could be a bot.

I've been trying to reach you about your car's extended warranty.

Robby78R said:

Huh, you guys are funny.
Who else is a bot?

Click to expand...

if i was a bot, how would i be able to send live pic and videos? lol

haha, no spam for me. i'm a vegan!