I feel me and Poe are going to have similar lists.
Mobile Game of the Year
I've played Hitman Go and it wasn't bad, this expands on that style of gameplay almost to another power. It's also really, really beautiful, not just for a mobile game, but for a game in general. It's great, it costs a dollar and it has no freemium bullshit tacked on.
Best game not made in 2015
Like Zero, I played a lot of this this year. Unlike Zero, I only played it for the first time this year. I'm now a devotee (still don't own a PS4 though, so no Bloodborne for me yet) and am waiting with baited breath for Dark Souls 3. I went on such a journey with this game, from hating invasions, to enjoying them, the becoming a theme invader, from struggling through a few hollow soldiers, to blindly being able to handle them, to doing a low SL run in order to get my theme invader his gear. I get it. Dark Souls is great.
Biggest Disappointment of 2015
I've been steeling myself for this one was going to turn out since, well, Fallout 3, but even I couldn't guess just how ass backwards Bethesda would get the roleplaying part of this open world FPS ROLEPLAYING game. The world really doesn't make any sense, even for a Bethesda game. For every one townsperson, there's at least 12000 raiders and gunners. There's a podcast I listen to called Watch Out for Fireballs where two guys do extensive playthroughs of old games and their last episode is on Fallout 3. They nail every hit on how Bethesda really didn't understand the source material they were making a game out of and Fallout 4 is no exception. Fallout 3 and 4 are the Star Wars Prequels of Fallout games.
Best of 2015, Frank Style
NUMBAH FIVE!
It's a rad space cowboy truckin' game. It has a wonderful soundtrack, fun gameplay, randomized universe and did I mention the soundtrack, because the soooooundtrack. It was also developed by TWO PEOPLE. Fuck. Great game.
NUMBAH FOUR!
I love Obsidian, I love old school CRPGS, I love Pillars of Eternity. I backed this bitch. It's great. It's for people like me.
NUMBAH THREE!
It's already been said that chapter two sucks and is rushed. That's true. Also, the game has all been but been ruined by Konami's trashy greed since it's release. Luckily I played my fill before that happened, or else I might have been just the most furious ball of fury. Chapter one is fucking awesome and the gameplay is fucking sublime. This, even without the Metal Gear trappings, is THE GOD DAMN BEST stealth action game. YOU CAN LIE ON THE GROUND AND MAKE YOUR HORSE SHIT ON YOU! Number three game of the year. Fuckonami.
NUMBAH TWO!
I've only owned this for two weeks and it's already got more hours in it from both me tinkering making level and from me just doing the 100 Mario challenge. I literally play at least an hour a day. This is the reason to own a Wii-U. It's incredible.
NUMBAH ONE!
Uh, yeah, this game was awesome. I can't wait for the next expansion so I can do the whole fucking thing over again. Loved it. Awesome game. This also has made me just moist for Cyberpunk. CDProject Red is my master now.