PvP LoL

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah I laughed at this one. Especially satisfying because I imagine Cole and Brent are standing at urinals while discussing inverted peeing.
 

Dave

Staff member
I didn't think it was funny simply because it's kinda dated. A week ago it would have been funny but now that joke has run its course.

I know Scott's been sick and so he has an excuse, but I think he missed the train on this one.
 
I think panel 2 would have been funnier if Batman were inverted, listening to his iPod, on a bus with a bunch of people staring at him.
 
T

ThatNickGuy

Wow. Morning missle brings new light to the "I'm going to cast...morning missile!" and "I attack the darkness!"
 
This just in... different people find different things funny.

I'm just sayin'... the "PA did it first" argument is a stretch. "Old joke is old" is kinda a stretch too.
 
This just in... different people find different things funny.

I'm just sayin'... the "PA did it first" argument is a stretch. "Old joke is old" is kinda a stretch too.
Maybe to you.

But literally, the first thing I thought of was "hey, didn't PA already do this joke?"
 
P

Philosopher B.

His main cast still looks weird compared with the rest of the strip. Good comic, though I preferred PA's, if only 'cause I love dialogue-free strips.
 
K

Kitty Sinatra

This just in... different people find different things funny.

I'm just sayin'... the "PA did it first" argument is a stretch. "Old joke is old" is kinda a stretch too.
Maybe to you.

But literally, the first thing I thought of was "hey, didn't PA already do this joke?"[/QUOTE]
And clicking your link we find that the answer is "no."
 
K

Kitty Sinatra

Let's look at the core of the jokes then:

1) Hanging upside down from a gargoyle is awesome!

2) No matter how stealthy you are, Batman is stealthier.

How are these the same joke?
 
Let's look at the core of the jokes then:

1) Hanging upside down from a gargoyle is awesome!

2) No matter how stealthy you are, Batman is stealthier.

How are these the same joke?
They both hang on the reader having a knowledge of the game and batman or else the joke fly over your head.
 
Shortpacked already made this joke. Well, not exactly made... It explained the basic mecanism behind it!

So, when I read this strip, I didn't think "Funny" or "stupid" but "duh, batman makes everything funny..."
 
Let's look at the core of the jokes then:

1) Hanging upside down from a gargoyle is awesome!

2) No matter how stealthy you are, Batman is stealthier.

How are these the same joke?
Both jokes are visual humor predicated on batman hanging upside down. The similarity is as obvious as, well, batman hanging upside down. You're just being obtuse.
 
PvP just never manages to be funny to me because it falls between two types of comedy that would work. His art style is that of more serious comics. Many of the jokes would really work better with his old-style art. For me facial expressions are everything in a visual joke and Scott sucks at it, full stop. Heck, one of the reasons I dislike CAD is because all his characters look like they're bored. But, PA strikes the right balance compared to them and heck, even if VGCATS isn't always great, the expressions on the faces and the style usually make up for it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top