As of this morning, Spielberg-defending, Up-panning New York Press contrarian Armond White is one of only a handful of critics holding District 9 back from a perfect 100 percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes — a hilarious fact that has so far inspired 542 irate comments and a campaign to have White removed from RT's listings. So last night, on his excellent blog, Roger Ebert, who liked District 9, chimed in with a typically thoughtful defense of White:
Yes, White disagrees with most people most of the time, and some people all of the time. Why is this a fault? He's an intelligent critic and a passionate writer, and he knows a very great deal about movies, dance, and many other things. His opinion is often valuable because it is outside the mainstream. He works for the New York Press, an alternative paper, and why should such a paper offer a conventional critic?
Then, presumably, he saw White's thumbs-up review of G.I. Joe.
This morning, Ebert added this to the top of his post:
On Thursday night I posted in [sic] entry in defense of Armond White's review of District 9. Overnight I received reader comments causing me to rethink that entry, in particular this eye-popping link supplied by Wes Lawson. I realized I had to withdraw my overall defense of White. I was not familiar enough with his work. It is baffling to me that a critic could praise Transformers 2 but not Synecdoche, NY. Or Death Race but not There Will Be Blood. I am forced to conclude that White is, as charged, a troll. A smart and knowing one, but a troll. My defense of his specific review of District 9 still stands.
Those people that became fuck consumerism and started fight clubs are generally morons, and completely missed the point of the entire movie. So, I'd take that as a good thing. It's definitely possible to love the movie and not take its "mantra" to heart.Garbledina said:I don't know why I like it so much, as I'm not one of those people who became super gung-ho "Yeah fuck consumerism" after the movie,
It ois only jsut coming out on DVD now? That makes no sense. i have seen it on tv multiple times, and even downloaded it over a year ago.ThatNickGuy said:The Mutant Chronicles
Screw District 9, folks, THIS is the sci-fi movie I wish had gotten more press. Sadly, it got crap for a theatre release and is now coming to DVD on Tuesday.
But look at it this way: it's got Punisher, Hellboy and deadly little Miho teaming up to fight space zombies. Well...okay, the actors that portrayed those characters are in this, but you get he idea. It's freaking awesome and even gets you to care a little bit about a lot of the usual expendable characters. Every one of them had a little moment where I said to my roommate, "I like him/her!"
Seriously, I really wish this flick could have gotten more press and better treatment in theatres. Check it out when you can.
hahahah, a couple of fat ass nerdy morons were behind us during the movie last ngiht night. At the end, when the credits rolled and folks were getting up to leave, one of the two announced loudly enough to make sure he was heard: "well, there is 2 and a half hours of my life I wont get back."Frankie said:Again, my enjoyment of the movie was marred by fat morons. Right behind me this rather rotund fellow thought every moment of the movie was worth roaring with laughter about. This would be fine if it were at the funny parts, but what really bothered me is when he laughed incredibly loudly at the scene where [spoiler:25d8q2b1]Vickers is being forced to test weapons and he's crying his eyes out pleading with the scientists not to make him murder the "Prawn" with the weapon.[/spoiler:25d8q2b1] Really *? That's hilarious to you? There's some concentration camp footage I think may bring a smile to your face you jiggly poop.
Shannow said:We were shocked, since it was such a good movie. My friend turn back, looked at him, and said "Dont worry, Transformers 2 is playing right down the hall. That should be more to your level of intelligence."
Knowing is half the battle!sixpackshaker said:I had a few eye rolls at the dialogue. Especially how they kept squeezing in the cartoon catch-phrases at odd times.
I freakin love Fallout.stienman said:nor eating enough chocolate frosted sugar bombs cereal.
-Adam
...You meant to say Calvin and Hobbes. I know that's what you meant to say. That had better be what you meant to say.Shegokigo said:I freakin love Fallout.stienman said:nor eating enough chocolate frosted sugar bombs cereal.
-Adam
One of my favorite recent movies. Snappy dialogue, great acting, wonderfully understated music (played on wineglasses!), etc. A good solid break from 3rd Rock from the Sun by Gordon-Levitt.drawn_inward said:Brick
Nice movie. Kids acting/speaking like adults was a bit odd, but it somehow worked. The script is cool, and most of the acting is quite good. I swear Levitt looks like Heath Ledger. Maybe he could fill his shoes to finish out the trilogy. It's worth a rental; especially if you like film noir.
He laughed at that?! It upset me so badly I almost cried out loud during that last part. That was one of the most horrible scenes I've seen in a while. The movie was great, touching. I loved the kid alien. I loved that final shot. Way to make me hate a guy and then suddenly root for him, movie.Frankie said:District 9 was fucking awesome. Straight up.
Again, my enjoyment of the movie was marred by fat morons. Right behind me this rather rotund fellow thought every moment of the movie was worth roaring with laughter about. This would be fine if it were at the funny parts, but what really bothered me is when he laughed incredibly loudly at the scene where [spoiler:282g4ctd]Vickers is being forced to test weapons and he's crying his eyes out pleading with the scientists not to make him murder the "Prawn" with the weapon.[/spoiler:282g4ctd] Really asshole? That's hilarious to you? There's some concentration camp footage I think may bring a smile to your face you jiggly shit.
I much preferred the original, because it had the whole psychological thrill aspect. The remake was just non-scary gore (to me). Plus, the skeleton rising from the acid is classic, and has been spoofed or copied about a billion times. Also, if it makes you feel any better, there were ghosts...they just showed up off-camera at the end.Shegokigo said:House on Haunted Hill - 1950's Version
Woefully starting to pick at the leftovers in the Netflix Instant Watch Horror selection (why is there never anything good in this genre for instant view?) I decided to watch a black and white Vincent Price flick I hadn't seen yet.
Being a fan of the "remake" I thought "Let's see where the inspiration comes from". Sadly I was dissapointed that it was just a murder mystery and not a supernatural horror. Still the awesomeness that is Price is more than enough reason to sit through this 1hr little film. He's still fantastic.
I didn't know it was wineglasses -- that's cool. The way the only 2 adults act in the movie is really interesting. It gave a vibe like the kids rule the world. Like Lord of the Flies meets The Maltese Falcon. Good stuff!fade said:One of my favorite recent movies. Snappy dialogue, great acting, wonderfully understated music (played on wineglasses!), etc. A good solid break from 3rd Rock from the Sun by Gordon-Levitt.drawn_inward said:Brick
Nice movie. Kids acting/speaking like adults was a bit odd, but it somehow worked. The script is cool, and most of the acting is quite good. I swear Levitt looks like Heath Ledger. Maybe he could fill his shoes to finish out the trilogy. It's worth a rental; especially if you like film noir.
I freaking loved this movie.Philosopher B. said:Death At A Funeral
Basically a modern-day screwball movie about a bunch of crazy British people getting mixed up at the head of the family's funeral. I thought it was pretty funny, and everything came together in the end nicely. Alan Tudyk was an absolute riot, though I could've done without seeing him blow spit bubbles naked, as well as the shit humor.