The Red Wings are like the Yankees in that veteran/experienced players sign with them in the hopes of winning championships. The Yankees have the advantage of being able to offer top level players obscene amounts of money with the chance at a championship, the Red Wings lure players with reputation. The Red Wings don't spend loads to bring in players, the players are willing to take pay cuts to play for them. I say that shows more about the character of hockey players. Baseball does have a luxury tax, the Yankees (and Red Sox) bring in enough revenue they can afford to pay the fines. According to wikipedia, the Detroit Tigers and LA Angels are the only other teams to pay the luxury tax.
Now, these are arguments that make some kind of sense. Meaning, they aren't generic neanderthal "hurrrf-a-durffff Wings = Yankees BOOOO" nonsense.
1) Can't argue the veteran players signing for less based on reputation. That's in fact one of the reasons that Kenny Holland is looked at as one of the best general managers of all of sports; he's able to negotiate that kind of thing, where 95% of other teams aren't. The question after this, however, becomes just how good are those veteran players? Hossa racked up the points during the regular season, but where was he during the Stanley Cup Finals last year when the Wings needed him? And lets not talk about the Bertuzzi thing; he may have score 4 goals in 2 games back-to-back, but he's still Todd friggin' Bertuzzi. Now Rafalski, Stuart, decent veteran free agent signings. But they aren't blockbuster Yankee-esque signings.
2) The Tigers have paid over on the luxury tax, yes, but poorly. This reflects upon the character of Mike Illitch, the owner, and the fans of the city of Detroit. Lemme explain.
We, in Detroit? We have nothing. The auto industry has crashed and burned; that was the one bright spot we HAD. Outside of it, the city is an urban cesspool of crime, underperforming public schools, and corruption. And as the city of Detroit goes, the state of Michigan goes. So everyone, regardless of geographical location within the state, is affected by the malaise and underperformance of the city. All we have is our sports. We obsess about them, probably way too much. Nonetheless that emotion, that feeling is still present. We've vaccinated ourselves against the Lions, thanks to near-centuries of frustration, but not so with the other sports. We count upon the Red Wings, the Tigers, Michigan Wolverines football, and Michigan State basketball. Most of all those Red Wings, as we are Hockeytown. We're an Original Six city, a founding city of North American hockey. Our general mood rises and falls as the fortunes of the Red Wings rise and fall. Second to that, however, is our Detroit Tigers. Mike Illitch owns them both. And where he has found success with the Red Wings, he has seen nothing but failure with the Tigers. You may count 2006 as a success, considering the Tigers made the playoffs, but look at their performance in that series. It was ABYSMAL. But Illitch? He, as much as any other blue collar Detroiter, wants to see championships in Detroit. He has the money, so he was willing to play the game in baseball in order to create a contending team. For that one year, he had the formula. But his general manager failed him. It wasn't spending the money that was the issue; it was giving the money to the wrong players. An 18 million dollar option to Magglio Ordonez, long-term big-money contracts to Brandon Inge, Jeremy Bonderman, Nate Robertson, and Dontrelle Willis. All of those contracts haunt the Tigers. So now? The Tigers are an utter shell of their former selves. They have had to trade their star developmental player, Curtis Granderson, as well as two of their three big free agent signings (Placido Polanco, Edwin Jackson) to the haves. Rendering the Tigers once again a have-not team.
Keep in mind the money spending was a new thing. Bolstered by the Red Wings' success, Illitch thought the same could happen for our Tigers. It didn't thanks to a less than intelligent general manager. But the reason money was spent wasn't out of arrogance, or a sense of entitlement. It was to bring some kind of accolades, of hope, of pride to a city that has literally nothing else to hang its hat upon. And that is why no Detroit team can
ever be compared to those New York Yankees.