Let me put my point another way. If someone started a thread about who was the best captain in Star Trek and only included Sisco, Janeway, and Archer, what would your reaction be?
Tom Baker, the 4th Doctor. He expanded the character and made it a better role for everyone that has followed. Plus, I'm old, so old will win because everything was better when I was a kid. (except for RC cars, they are much, much better now)