The reason Toonami was awesome to most of you was because otherwise you had no access to the anime they were showing. You couldn't afford to buy the box VHS sets, if they even had sets available for purchase. However you are not a child anymore, you either own or have seen the series' they pass on it or will pass on the new one multiple times. There's zero reason for you to catch an episode or two out of sequence just because it's airing. Sure you'll watch one or two here if you remember it being good but you won't watch an entire season intently (with lots of commercial interruption). New anime fans also won't stay and watch entire seasons, if they see an episode of something interesting, they'll watch it, maybe half of it and then go download/buy the series.
Toonami was a product of it's age and no longer has a place in this era of TV/HULU/NETFLIX/ARRRRBAY technology.