Maybe not, but it's the same type of gadgets/extras you get these days in collector's editions and special editions - and people still seem to be buying these. I do understand up to a point: if you had a "budget" edition which is just a bare disc, a "normal" edition with a paper manual and one or two extras, and a "collector's" edition with everything, the middle one would probably sell worst of the three. It's the one I'd prefer these days, but back when I played more games, I'd probably have had to go for the first.....Eh.