I just rewatched Top Gun for the first time in probably decades. It's interesting to see how different a 30 year old movie is today than when you first watched it. It's a movie with problems.
I mean, even putting aside the rampant inaccuracies (Migs carrying French exocet missiles? F-14s DOGFIGHTING WITH GUNS??) and repeated use of the same aviation footage again and again, and the fact that the narration of the action sequences seldom actually match what is happening on screen, AND putting aside the fact that of course the "MiG 28s" are actually F-5s because where the heck would hollywood come by an actual MiG 28 in 1985, and especially putting aside the idea that the Indian Ocean would possibly have "enemy territory" for a disabled US ship to drift into in the first place, much less territory of an enemy equipped with cutting edge MiG fighters...
..Even putting aside ALL that...
... the first half of the movie is a disjointed headache. It seems less a coherent story than a montage of unconnected events. No rhyme, reason or motivation that carries the viewer from one scene to the next other than "oh, I guess this is what is happening now, whatever this is." I was starting to get a little depressed at how badly the movie was failing to measure up to my nostalgia for it.
And then Goose died.
And holy shit did the movie suddenly become oscar material. The directing vastly improves. The story actually flows in a way that is understandable from scene to scene, as opposed to the previous jarring experience. The actors actually have to start showing more emotion and depth than simple swaggering bravado, and they do. The conflict within Tom Cruise's character is communicated expertly without verbal exposition, and the various characters dealing with the loss and the need to move on form a tableau. Maverick loses his mojo, learns about his father's mysterious death, gets his mojo back. It's powerful stuff.
It's funny how all the "boring" parts I wished would be over so they could get back to blowing up stuff when I was a kid is what turns out to carry this movie in the eyes of an adult.
So yeah, it's a movie with problems, but it redeems itself amazingly in the fourth and fifth reel.