[Webcomic] PVP Discussion

S

Soliloquy

All right, I've just got to say: This past story arc? Amazing. It's not geeky humor (which is why most of us got into PvP to begin with) but it proves that Scott does still have some serious writing skills. So much so that it has me typing in italics.​
Scott does relationship arcs really well, it seems. Just so long as he doesn't take an arc that shouldn't be a relationship arc and force it into being one (I'm looking at you, Mines of Madness).​
 
His art though has been increasingly going back to being bland and boring. He seems to be recycling his art between panels more and more. These days PVP looks more static than almost as static as CAD.
 

GasBandit

Staff member
Hrrrmmm.. I don't think I agree there. Today's comic may be a little static, but the few before that were manifestly different from frame to frame.
 
Yeah, I'm pretty happy with this arc. So far anyway (he still has time to ruin it, of course). But if/when Francis and Marcy end up getting together I'll feel like they earned it first.
 
Yeah, I'm pretty happy with this arc. So far anyway (he still has time to ruin it, of course). But if/when Francis and Marcy end up getting together I'll feel like they earned it first.
For sure. My favourite long-running PVP arc was the year or so that Brent and Jade were broken up. It'd be cool to have something like that again. Especially if people keep giving Francis bad advice, or he keeps misinterpreting it.
 
S

Soliloquy

I'm pretty sure Scott avoids this place like you would an angry ex girlfriend.
 
And now he's doing ANOTHER comic, this time for Namco Bandai's Shiftylook site. Expect him to drop The Trenches now that he has a new project.
 
Or he'll update for the first 3 or 4 comics on time, then then gradually get later and later with each update before silently dropping the project entirely. But not before completely re-purposing the comic halfway through, maybe hiring on a new artist, claiming the new direction will totally give him time to update more, seriously this time you guys!

Reference

On the plus side, apparently Straub is also involved in this newest project. I seem to enjoy anything Scott and Kris do together, so there should be hope for this.
 
Today's doesn't make sense. Either Cole is blatantly mistaken and the joke doesn't work too well, or his large intestine is filled 25 years worth of unreleased poop. Or he can poop while also holding in farts, in which case he should call his ass "John Goodman". 'Cause its big and talented.
 
And now he's doing ANOTHER comic, this time for Namco Bandai's Shiftylook site. Expect him to drop The Trenches now that he has a new project.
He won't drop the trenches. PA is involved with it, and if it even looks like he's late on his art, Khoo will appear in his room in the dead of night and force him to draw.
 

Necronic

Staff member
Today's doesn't make sense. Either Cole is blatantly mistaken and the joke doesn't work too well, or his large intestine is filled 25 years worth of unreleased poop. Or he can poop while also holding in farts, in which case he should call his ass "John Goodman". 'Cause its big and talented.
Or....you know...it's a joke.
 
If Jade gets pregnant (in a very special PvP) and has a miscarriage, I will laugh until I puke.

But you just know that they are going to have a kid now. And the hijinks are going to be wacky.
Tonight it finally hit me what's going to happen with the whole pregnancy arc. There won't be one. Jade or Brent will have fertility issues. Isn't Scott unable to have children or am I remembering wrong again?
 

North_Ranger

Staff member
I think there's been at least some talk about him not being able to have children or something. Can't recall if he himself has said anything, and frankly I'm not too interested in Scott's junk or its capabilities.

But still, I gotta say that if this pregnancy arc hits that kind of a wall... I am gonna go and call bullshit. First of all, I don't think Scott the tastemaker no longer has the maturity of discussing such a sensitive and painful matter without making it either forced or completely idiotic... and second, it would just show that his incapability to express human emotions and experiences beyond what he himself has undergone. And that's a big weakness for a storyteller of any kind.

I'm hoping, but frankly I'm not hopeful.
 
Tonight it finally hit me what's going to happen with the whole pregnancy arc. There won't be one. Jade or Brent will have fertility issues. Isn't Scott unable to have children or am I remembering wrong again?
Wouldn't that be a lot of projecting himself into the comic and not having ideas of his own, in some way?

But then Brent and Jade couldn't have a wedding of their own but did reenact Scott's.

That fact and the handling of the Francis-Marcy-arc after the deed was done was the straw to breakt his comic camel's back for me, shark-jumping might have been even a bit earlier.
 
I don't think that's fair, N_R.

He has gone on record saying that he is infertile. You write what you know...and he was a man that wanted children, couldn't have them and now has this on his shoulders.

I believe he has enough tact to be able to handle such a situation well...if not for himself than for his wife.

I don't see 'writing what you know' to be a weakness at all.
 
Top