I'm late on this one..... I'm kind on the fence on this.
Here is the problem.
People commit crimes. It could be low level crime (shoplifting) to high level (mass murder, ponzi scheme etc etc) the level of punishment should fit the crime right?
BUT then we have a 2nd problem.
Once you commit a crime, get caught, serve time, and then release. you have a record. This record is NOT going away (unless you are under 18 and turn 18 then there are some exceptions) it is REALLY hard to get a job after that. How can a person who may or may not be rehabilitated ever go back into society?
I can totally understand where people might not want that kind of element in their workplace cause SOME cases, these criminal lapse back into their old way and we can't have that in our workplace BUT some never turn back to crime and continue on (when given the chance).
Regardless of the crime, should ex-con be readmit to society? if answer is yes, then we have to decide WHICH crime are allow, and which crime are not BUT if we don't allow them back into society, what are we going to do with them? if you just release them back into the world and the world don't accepts them, then that element just go back to criminal ways so they can get back to jail and enjoy roof over their head and meals.
Now, this person's crime was dog fighting. In some society this is a sick sport. Dogs are starved, drugged, trained to kill other dogs. It is pure manipulation of animal for people's entertainment. What about horse racing? how is that allow? my wife knows quite a bit of horses and train some. She tells me that horse races, these horses are push to the limit and then some are just let to die when they can't run anymore. They are drugged (against the law) to boost performance. Same with Dog racing. Sure other animals doesn't get killed by their kind, but still as bad (in my book). Cock Fighting are allow in some country. Some country allows to eat dogs.
I guess for those people who don't think Vick should NOT return to NFL. What should he do now? does he have other skills? or is he one of those "typical football player" who are given a free pass cause he is good at football and has no skill? (kinda old stereotypical stigma, but I know that is not true for all sports player) What is this person allow to do after serving his time? should he be put back into prison and let OUR tax dollar let this man ride free?
Or there should be a higher punishment for certain crime? some might say death is extreme and many states doesn't really "execute" as many people per year. I recently saw on cable (forgot which channel) on how many people are still on death row after 10+ years.