So first, I want to say that Gal Gadot was perfectly cast. I thought she did a terrific job of making the character come to life, and I'm glad my impressions of her in B v S were correct. I also thought a lot of the action was fantastic (although too many 'slowdowns'). I came out of the movie generally enjoying it. The rest of my family who have seen it all that it was just awesome.
Criticism time!
I wasn't really into most of the beginning. The whole Themyscira section of the movie didn't grab me, and I was actually starting to get concerned when watching the film. I thought it was a little too full of typical movie cliches. You know, the disapproving mother, the training in secret, the discovery of training which had apparently been happening for years but just now was being discovered even though they seemed to be training in broad daylight right out in the open, and then,
naturally, the death of the mentor.
Of course.
Also, I didn't 100% understand her mother's beliefs or motivations.
1. She clearly believes Ares is still around. Or not. I think. At least the movie seems to imply that she believes it enough to not want to tell Diana anything about her origins.
2. She does not trust/care that Diana can actually kill Aeries as a 'weapon to slay gods'.
3. 'Men'--or I guess, non-Amazons, aren't worth the effort in saving.
Was then, trying to make sure Diana wasn't trained or knowledgeable in her origin (even though she flat out says- u r not amazonian lol), just a giant middle finger to Zeus' last saving through against Ares in an effort to protect Diana or what? Also what was the basis that knowing how to fight or knowing her origins would 'allow Ares to find her'? Even if it was true, would the Final Fantasy victory fanfare play over the island's loudspeakers if the world turned to ash due to Ares influence and Themyscira was left untouched?
Where
is Themyscira anyway? So he's in Turkey and flew away right? First, hope he was flying to a nearby allied base, because he isn't flying to England in that thing. Second, that might put it somewhere in the Mediterranean or Black sea, but if that were the case, you kind of assume people would be running into the island all the time throughout history. Perhaps its Amazonian policy to simply shoot anyone on sight--but I kind of wish they had said something to that effect. It gets more muddied when they sail from Themyscira and right into London. There is a 0% change he flew anywhere near the English channel in that plane (and if Themyscira was in the English Channel, that would raise more questions), but they just seem to sail there overnight. I mean, I guess we're going to have to go with "
magic" here.
Also, why can she never come back again? Was that established in the movie at all? It is just something you nod your head and say, 'Well yes, if you leave the secret island of Amazon warriors, you can't ever return for reasons. Makes sense". I mean, in the DCAU I recall her going back to Themyscira on more than one occasion, so I don't know if this is its own movie lore coming out, or is there something I don't know?
I thought they should have done more with the WW I setting. I don't like the fact that the essentially turned the Germans into Nazi stand-ins. Having
omg gas as the doomsday weapon was silly, when gas was being used by
all sides for
years. It wasn't a German-only thing. There wasn't some "doctor poison" running around--and it's highly unlikely that even if the gas in the movie had been used--that it would have done anything to win the war, especially since we're apparently a day or so away from signing an armistice. Also, Luddendorf, what did they do to you? Historical Luddendorf was a much more interesting person (oh, and anti-Nazi prior to his death), than the Saturday-morning cartoon villain they used him as in the movie. In fact, it was over the top enough that I saw the "twist" coming a mile away. The whole "super gas" he sniffed to give him a chance vs Wonder Woman was a bit silly too.
I had issues with Ares as well. I liked the whole "I'm behind the scenes feein' ur thoughts" aspect, but other parts of the character fell short. I don't like the fact that he's apparently looked like a British Lord since...well forever. That cheeky mustache peeking out from behind that helmet was hilarious in the wrong way. They should have went all the way and gave him a shadowy face and red eyes.
I thought Chris Pine did pretty well, although I kept seeing Captain Kirk. The other supporting characters were OK, but not very much was done with them. Perhaps much didn't need to be done with them.
Other than that, I thought it was pretty good