Shegokigo said:
Your first one just makes me
Second one I'd considered tied.
If you'd like to list more I'm all ears. This is genuine curiousity, as one of the films that comes to mind that I prefer is "Metropolis".
Beauty and the Beast was fairly groundbreaking in a few ways, and there isn't a bad scene in the entire thing. It's gorgeous to look at, has great characters, the music is entertaining and drives the story (essential for a musical). It's a beautiful story that has been told over and over again, and this is a great retelling. It's my favorite Disney movie.
As for Spirited Away, I find it far more personal than Princess Mononoke. This is unsurprising considering Mononoke approaches a sprawling epic. But the world in Spirited Away is so rich and deep, and the characters are so great, and it has some breathtakingly beautiful animation. It's just a notch above Mononoke in my book.
I might also put My Neighbor Totoro above Mononoke, depending on my mood.
Some others that I'd put right up there with Mononoke, perhaps but not necessarily above it:
Triplets of Belleville
Finding Nemo
WALL-E
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Fantasia
But yeah, Mononoke is definitely high up on the list of greatest animated films.
Ravenpoe said:
That's because after Beauty and the Beast, the academy created the best animated film category, so that no more of those lousy 'cartoons' would be poking their nose in with the 'real' films again
Nah, the real reason they added that category is so that they could honor and draw attention to MORE animated films, and give animated films in general higher honors than they would normally get. Unfortunately for the Academy, since then, Pixar has started making movies that have sort of languished in Best Animated purgatory, sort of undoing what the Academy really wanted to do with that category.