The other problem I'm running into with Netflix, aside from quality, is the limited time some things have. Just recently, I wanted to start watching Sons of Anarchy. I even had it in my instant que for when such a time would occur. And now it's gone. And I have a cap on how much I can download.
But I'm the same way
Gilgamesh. I have a 1.5 TB portable drive with a crap load of movies, shows, documentaries, and cartoons. Most of my collection are ones that used to be on my shelves, either in VHS or DVD form. But the majority of them, I just don't need all the bells and whistles of special features, just the movie. The studios have more than gotten my money from most of my collection, since I've seen them in theatres, rented them a gazillion times, bought many of them (VHS, DVD, some BluRay), etc. And I'm tired of moving from format to format when I don't give a rats ass about special features. For
some movies, like anything by Pixar or the Marvel movies, it's definitely worth it to get the BluRay. Everything else? Screw it.
But yeah, Ash is right. I miss game rentals. When I worked at Blockbuster, I got to try a lot of games I ordinarily wouldn't try. I also miss just perusing the shelves and spotting something interesting or something I hadn't seen in a long time. This sometimes works with Netflix, but cripes, the ratio of crap to great leans very strongly on the crap side.
Right now, "legally obtaining" something online is the best, fastest, most reliable service. I don't do it for games, partly because I don't think you really can (at least for PS3) and partly because games is where I won't pirate.