My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU (Seasons 1 and 2)
Genre: Romance, Comedy, High School, Harem(ish)
Fanservice: None really to speak of
Premise: Hachiman Hikigaya is an apathetic high school student with narcissistic and semi-nihilistic tendencies. He firmly believes that joyful youth is nothing but a farce, and everyone who says otherwise is just lying to themselves. In a novel punishment for writing an essay mocking modern social relationships, Hachiman's teacher forces him to join the Volunteer Service Club, a club that aims to extend a helping hand to any student who seeks their support in achieving their goals. With the only other club member being the beautiful ice queen Yukino Yukinoshita, Hachiman finds himself on the front line of other people's problems—a place he never dreamed he would be. As Hachiman and Yukino use their wits to solve many students' problems, will Hachiman's rotten view of society prove to be a hindrance or a tool he can use to his advantage?
It starts off with a rather interesting premise - Hikigaya is a misanthrope of the first order, forced into a club whose aim is to help people, and is paired off against an aloof, intelligent, beautiful girl - which, as an unpopular scoundrel, grates on him even more. It has a lot of interesting episodes with unconventional resolutions, many of which involve Hikigaya martyring himself for people he doesn't claim to care much about - he explains it away as because nobody likes him to begin with, it's nothing for him to solve people's problems by becoming the bad guy, whether it be as a common enemy to unite vacillating friends, or throwing himself on a metaphorical grenade of embarrasment so someone else doesn't have to. Over the course of the show's run, his distaste for other people slowly cracks away, revealed to be the defense mechanism it always was, and his classmates accordingly also come to appreciate him - or at least become less repulsed by him. And, naturally, a love triangle begins to develop where nobody can come right out and say what they're feeling because then we wouldn't have a show.
It seems to borrow a lot from its contemporaries (I especially see a lot of direct parallels between this and Toradora), but doesn't shine as brightly as any of them, and frankly a lot of what it tries to do, Bunny Girl Senpai did better (albeit later). Despite all that, it's an entertaining watch... until about halfway into the second season. Then it just all kind of goes off the rails and becomes a slog. Most irritatingly of all, none of the primary conflicts of the show's overall plot arc are resolved by the end of season 2, and season 3 is probably a long ways out, if ever, as it is apparently waiting for more LN/Manga source material.
So, I guess what I'm trying to say is, it's really only worth watching right now if you have nothing much else to do, and are looking for ANYTHING you haven't watched yet as a fix for an anime craving itch you just can't seem to scratch.
Verdict: OK (2.5/5)