I think it gets good reviews because it hits that weird spot where it's available for free online, so you can't really complain because hey, free! At the same time though, you can pay for it through Patreon - twice weekly, every week, for quite a while now - so the people doing that have maybe payed out more than they would have for an actual professionally published book so if it's not actually that good then they're idiots - kind of a sunk costs fallacy element?This thing gets huge glowing reviews on Goodreads and Amazon and I just don't understand why. Are our bars so low?
Our bars may not be, but I could point you to several other threads where we discuss exactly how low many bars are these days.Are our bars so low?
James Cameron needs to hurry up and release Avatar 2 already...Our bars may not be, but I could point you to several other threads where we discuss exactly how low many bars are these days.
—Patrick
Why though?James Cameron needs to hurry up and release Avatar 2 already...
Anyone who says they don't count is wrong.Do audiobooks count as "reading"? Fuck it. I'm counting it.
Help! I'm listening to the audiobook of one of my all-time favourite books - Hominids, by Robert J Sawyer - and I can't stop! It's too engaging! The science fiction is too fascinating! Damn you, Audible Canada for your Canadian book sale AND $5 credit, making it so cheap to get.
Seriously, the Neanderthal Parallax trilogy aren't just some of my all-time favourite science fiction books. They're some of my all-time favourite books in general. I WISH I could write sci-fi like Robert J Sawyer.
The only argument I could see against them is in listening to it rather than reading it, you're not observing the structure of the writing. You can follow the plot, character, themes, etc, but you can't really see how the writer utilizes writing from a structural point of view. Punctuation, paragraphs, etc. Which, I suppose if one wanted to study the work from an academic standpoint, that would make sense,Anyone who says they don't count is wrong.
They've done studies. Our brains treat it the same. Listening to an audiobook is reading; you're good.The only argument I could see against them is in listening to it rather than reading it, you're not observing the structure of the writing. You can follow the plot, character, themes, etc, but you can't really see how the writer utilizes writing from a structural point of view. Punctuation, paragraphs, etc. Which, I suppose if one wanted to study the work from an academic standpoint, that would make sense,
Well they're wrong about it being a big deal, or some sort of wrong/lesser way to enjoy/take-in a story. Especially since oral transmission of stories likely predates writing.Anyone who says they don't count is wrong.
Tell that to my brain, who just tunes out in minutes (i blame school, it made me really good at tuning out people talking at me).They've done studies. Our brains treat it the same.
I just think it will be better once it has the other book to go with it. It's very much a lead in to something else.I just picked up my copy of Peace Talks. I've heard mixed. Some love it, some are just meh.
Nope not doing that one again.And part of a trilogy, of which part two ... just released,
I've still got a Kingkiller-shaped-dagger in my back. I don't think Rothfuss is ever going to finish, now.Nope not doing that one again.
Remind me when they're all out, then we'll talk.
The third book in the Trilogy, Alecto the Ninth, is currently slated for 2021. Given that Muir broughtout Harrow the Ninth despite (or perhaps thanks to?) the current goings on in the world, I'd say that bodes well for her track record. But sure. I'll post again in a year.Nope not doing that one again.
Remind me when they're all out, then we'll talk.