GasBandit
Staff member
Oh, it gets even worse.So, I've been playing some LA Noire, just finished the traffic desk, and I'm sorry to say I've grown bored of it already. It's a well-crafted game, but it just can't keep my interest.
I think the problem is that I realized there's no real penalty to screwing up a case. I could botch my way through every investigation, and no matter what happens I'll still be able to move on to the next one, and get promoted after a few cases. The game is happy to just merrily move me along the next set of rails, telling me the story it wants to tell.
Now, granted, there's nothing wrong with telling a story, but usually you'd want the game to be as immersive as possible for maximum storytelling effectiveness. And here LA Noire falls short again, because I keep running into things that break immersion. The aforementioned ability to be a star cop even if you screw up every case, for one. The ability to just ignore your current case and go gallivanting through the city looking for gunfights and fisticuffs is another. All of this combines to remind me that I'm not really playing a game, I'm watching a lengthy movie with moderately interactive segments.
So, new plan. I'm just gonna barrel through the rest of the game, picking "doubt" on every question, and enjoy Cole acting like a psychopath. There is probably a strong case to be made for this being the "wrong" way to play the game. Don't really care, for me it's either play it wrong or don't play it at all.
Major spoiler -
Even if you ace every single case, turns out you were wrong anyway - the final case reveals all your previous collars were dead wrong and it was one politician's son who did all the murders. Which was infuriating because I saw it coming a mile (and a half dozen cases) away but there was no way in the game for me to say "Stop, wait, this guy didn't do it, all these cases are clearly connected, if not the work of a single man, and we need to let this guy go." NOPE. Just blunder through doing what you know to be wrong and then act all surprised in the final case! Gagghhh.