From reading the review, it seems like the reviewer did in fact play it. And enjoyed it, and even wrote several paragraphs about how amazingly great the gameplay was. But he said the sexual content broke his immersion, which ok, I can totally see someone having that reaction, especially if they're not comfortable with that sort of imagery. The hubbub comes from the fact that he lowered the score he awarded it because he didn't like the sexiness, and felt it was sexist. I would argue over why that is or isn't a problem, except for the fact that all number scores are arbitrary anyway and trying to take it seriously starts to make my brain hurt.