Ok, so this last week or so, when I go to bed, I've been putting Ruroni Kenshin on. I'd seen bits and pieces of it previously but never watched the whole thing. I'm up to about episode 20 now.
Something about it doesn't rub me the right way. Sometimes I feel like I'm watching Ranma 1/2 all over again, and sometimes I feel like I'm watching Inuyasha all over again. For a series that gets such glowing reviews, it sure does seem to lean heavily on stock anime tropes sometimes. I'm not sure it's any one thing I can really pin down, but there's a lot of little things that bother me.
Is it entirely necessary to say the full "Kenshin's reverse-blade sword" every time someone refers to Kenshin's reverse-blade sword? I mean, surely once or so an episode would be more than sufficient to point out that Kenshin's sword is reverse-bladed.
Also there seems to be a bit of anachronism in the works here... the setting is 10 years after the Meiji restoration, which would put it in the late 1870s or thereabout, but I just saw a clearly early-20th century cruise liner in a harbor. Completely metal with visible rivets, in an era when even iron-clad wooden ships are cutting edge technology - and limited to rivers at that. Not only that, but soldiers seem to have semi-automatic rifles, which I guess isn't THAT bad in comparison, as the first one was invented in 1885 in Germany, though really they didn't start entering common use until the 1900s. I suppose they could have just been lazily animated bolt-action rifles.
Also, they kind of overestimate the deadliness of a gatling gun when used indoors against opponents spread wider than a 90 degree arc and closer than 20 yards.
Yahiko is one of the most irritating junior characters since Scrappy-Doo.
All that aside, it does very well at capturing the bitterness of a time of change, when the old ways are dying out to be replaced by new ways that aren't necessarily better, in the same way the movie The Last Samurai did.
It's fun playing spot-the-voice-actor though, as the english voice cast is comprised of the same guys that basically did ALL anime 10 or 15 years ago. Dat 90s soundtrack, doe.