I pirated DQXI. I'm 30 hours in and it feels like it's just now starting to get "good," true to JRPG form.
Up until now it's felt like a big ol' Fisher Price My First RPG rated Y7+ for Puff Puff. But despite the simplicity and shallow family-friendliness, I am really digging some parts of it.
I absolutely LOVE that you can switch out party members even in the middle of a fight, and that everybody in your stable gets exp even if they're not in the party when it ends. The biggest source of angst I've had in RPGs previously of this nature was in selecting party members and worrying about my choices later. Gone. Everybody comes, even if only 4 people are active at any one moment.
The crafting system isn't bad either, it's a novel take on it, though I can see why the switch edition changed up things like letting you craft anywhere - it's a bit irritating to have to go camping whenever you want to craft.
I kinda feel like the dude in the review oversold a few aspects of the game... he went on and on about how massive and intricate all the cities are, and let me tell you, coming from MMOs like Conan Hyborean Adventures or Warhammer Online, or heck, just RPGs like Beyond Divinity 1 and 2... these cities are tiny and simple. And going with midi for the soundtrack is kind of a strange choice - said soundtrack ranging between corny and cheesy, occasionally repetitive AF. But he was right about one thing - this is an excellent game to play when you want to relax and "hang out" and not think too hard. I especially like how the AI controls characters if you tell it to do so - it usually makes the choices I would want it to in any given situation. I also agree that this game is only as grindy as you make it, and also only as easy or as hard as you want it to be. I stop fighting mooks as soon as it feels like I'm not being given enough exp for victories to make it worthwhile (which usually leads to me dodging a LOT of battles by sprinting around monsters crono trigger style), and so far that seems to be the sweet spot for making the boss fights slightly challenging but not overwhelming. I've never had a total party wipe, but I did stop and reload saves once or twice due to botched minigames (for which I blame the keyboard controls, they're HORRIBLE in the horse race, I plugged my controller in specifically for that part and that part only) or RNG crafting fuckery.
I'll tell you one thing though, ESC on the keyboard being "immediately quit without saving" instead of "open system menu" is a HORRIBLE design choice.
Anyway, I'll still probably buy it once it gets to be 10 bucks on steam.