Man beats and kills 2 year old for spilling his milk

Status
Not open for further replies.
http://www.truecrimereport.com/2010/03/manuel_garcia_beats_jovani_mar.php


Jovani Martinez, as 2-year-olds are wont to do, was fooling around with his milk bottle, causing it to spill. This didn't sit well with Manuel Garcia, the boyfriend of the toddler's mother, Lawanda Martinez. So he decided to forcefully make his displeasure known...

He threw the toddler onto a mattress, but Jovani got back up. So Garcia began to pummel him, punching him in the kidneys, stomach and chest.

Mother Lawanda Martinez would later take the boy to visit his grandma, Wanda Williams, in Racine, Wisconsin that day. Grandma noticed that Jovani was barely conscious, kept falling, couldn't stand up on his own and was shaking. She urged Martinez to take Jovani to the the hospital.

But mom said he always acted this way and took him home. She gave him Tylenol that evening. But by 11:30, she noticed that his body had gone cold and his lips blue.

By the time they arrived at the hospital, Jovani's kidney's were failing. He wouldn't survive. A pathologist discovered that his intestines were perforated, his liver and pancreas were lacerated, and he had broken ribs. This wasn't something that could be caused by accident.

Garcia, 40, has now been charged with reckless homicide. Martinez, 23, is charged with neglect of a child causing death.



:facepalm:

This is just depressing and sick





(oh and in before any jokes about crying over spilled milk)
 
Why do people post these things? We all agree this is sick and sad and wrong. There's nothing about it to discuss.
 
Why do people post these things? We all agree this is sick and sad and wrong. There's nothing about it to discuss.
Usually this evolves into a discussion about what would be an appropriate punishment for the accused in the story. If it does go that route, here's hoping it'll remain civil.
 
I don't get how the mom didn't notice that the child was acting strange but the grandmother did.

I suppose I just have to frame of reference though for how a 2 year old acts. Are they big enough to walk around? Could the child have expressed in some way what happened?
 
W

Wasabi Poptart

A two year old can walk around, but may not have the capacity to explain what has happened or how he feels physically or emotionally. When my son was that young and he was feeling sick, he would throw a temper tantrum of epic proportions and tell me how he didn't love me anymore while he was screaming and crying. Next thing I knew he'd have a fever and usually come down with croup that night.

Do I believe the mom didn't see something was wrong with her child? Hell no. She knew.
 
A

Andromache

Can we please bring back public capital and corporate punishment now?
 
M

makare

Aw that is so sad. We need a forum just called Really Depressing Shit so I can just stay out of it.
 
I

Iaculus

Yeah. Just ask Iaculus.
Weirdly enough, this is actually accurate this time. My dad's several years older than my mum, and they've got one of the most stable, loving relationships I've encountered.

They didn't meet when my mum was fourteen, though. Just so's I make that clear.

Re: punishment, I don't see what the problem with life imprisonment is here. It's cheaper than the death penalty, and... well, dude's a childkiller. It's not like he's going to have a fun time of it there.
 
Can we please bring back public capital and corporate punishment now?
No, Charlie won't allow it. It's Charlie's world, this guy will spend his days in prison.[/QUOTE]

LEAVE CORPORATIONS ALONE........ they're humans being too, don't you know.


A two year old can walk around, but may not have the capacity to explain what has happened or how he feels physically or emotionally.
Also, bleeding internally from half your organs impairs most peoples capacities anyhow...
 
Re: punishment, I don't see what the problem with life imprisonment is here. It's cheaper than the death penalty, and... well, dude's a childkiller. It's not like he's going to have a fun time of it there.
Only marginally, after you factor in the cost of appeals over a period of time. But yes, he would not do well in prison.
 
I still can't wrap my head around the fact that the death sentence costs MORE than 70+ years in prison. You guys should just kill these scumbags in a humane yet cheap and quick way... bullet to the head. That's it. No more million-dollar injections/red tape.

How's THAT for a liberal's view?
 
Speaking as an officer in a system that has had a cop-killer on death row for 20 years (Google Troy Davis, if you're curious), I have few problems with your liberal view, Calleja.
 
I'm the anti-church, pro-choice, pro-gay liberal who sees more and more sense in Eugenics, though, so I don't think I count much.
 
I still can't wrap my head around the fact that the death sentence costs MORE than 70+ years in prison. You guys should just kill these scumbags in a humane yet cheap and quick way... bullet to the head. That's it. No more million-dollar injections/red tape.

How's THAT for a liberal's view?
The act of executing a prisoner does not cost more. The lengthy round of automatic appeals, especially lawyer fees, cost more than a life sentence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top